MISD special ed review finds need for immediate action on safety
What happened: Midland ISD publicly released its report on its special education program, following last year’s special education investigation of South Elementary. The report found major gaps in student safety practices, caseloads stretched well past recommended levels, inconsistent placement decisions, and a general lack of attention to students with special needs.
The 84-page report describes “a district under significant operational strain” and says safety systems, placement practices, implementation of students’ individualized education programs (IEPs), staffing and compliance structures “require immediate attention.”
Why it matters: The board was not legally required to release but voted 4-3 with trustees Dr. Friez, Mr. Guinn, Mr. Hernandez, and Mr. Hodges supporting the release. In supporting his vote to release the report Dr. Friez stated “We owe our community the opportunity to independently evaluate the institutions the support and the trustees they elect. There are risks to consider, but there is also enduring public value in transparency”. Sara Burleson in opposition to releasing the report stated “That’s good theory, but when there’s a legal lawsuit, then to me, that’s a huge red flag until the legal case is over.”
MISD enrolled about 3,800 special education students in 2024-25. For those families, the findings raise serious concerns about whether children are safe in self-contained classrooms, whether they receive the services written into their Individualized Education Programs (IEP), and how long families wait for an evaluation.
The report says MISD is doing enough of the required procedural actions to earn a Texas Education Agency (TEA) designation of level 2 compliance, “Needs Assistance.” MISD is not attempting to comply with the spirit of the special education programs and “remains at risk of tipping from ‘Needs Assistance’ into ‘Needs Intervention.” per the report.
Student safety: The district has installed cameras in most, if not all, self-contained special education classrooms, but the report says the installation only partially meets state law. Texas Education Code 29.022 requires cameras that cover all areas of the classroom, including any attached timeout room, and record audio from all areas.
In explaining the shortcomings, the report directly quotes that the district lacks “clear ownership of responsibility across departments, and documented procedures for storage, retention, and access to video and audio recordings.”
The review also found restraint documentation is inconsistent across campuses, and parent notification timelines of restraint use are not consistently met or documented. Crisis prevention training does not keep pace with staff turnover, and incident investigations lack standardized protocols. The district has no formal, districtwide system for documenting seclusion or timeout.
A separate consultant MISD hired in fall 2025 to observe specialized programs also found its most serious concern was supervision in Behavior Support Classrooms. That consultant also documented students sitting idle, over-reliance on tablets, minimal direct instruction, and long-term substitutes leading high-needs classrooms.
This report found an aligned conclusion with the fall 2025 report, stating, “MISD lacks a districtwide framework for instructional expectations in specialized programs, resulting in inconsistent instructional quality and potential FAPE risks.” FAPE refers to the Free Appropriate Public Education in a federal 1975 law on special education.
Discipline: The report found many students with disabilities were punished for behavior linked to unmet needs and exceeded allowable days out of their placement. It also found campuses do not understand the difference between mandatory and discretionary DAEP placements for students with disabilities. The elementary DAEP is not staffed with special education teachers, and the district temporarily reassigned two specialists to cover IEP services there.
The report also cites “ongoing staff injuries related to aggressive student behavior,” often in classrooms without adequate behavior plans or crisis systems. Students receiving special education services were involved in 383 out-of-school suspension incidents in the 2025-26 school year and 147 placements in DAEP.
Evaluations: Educational diagnosticians, who conduct evaluations that determine whether a student qualifies for special education, carry caseloads ranging from 60 to 236 students, compared with a recommended 60 to 80 active cases.
As of March 2, the district had 571 pending initial referrals, including 117 requiring bilingual assessments. The report estimates those referrals represent 11,400 to 17,100 hours of evaluation work, the equivalent of six to nine full-time diagnosticians. When pending referrals are factored in, 84% of diagnosticians are working at elevated or critical levels. The most burdened diagnostician was responsible for 361 students and 84 active referrals across three campuses. Two campuses have no dedicated diagnosticians.
The report says the district had numerous evaluations with “compromised timelines” and faces “urgent challenges in meeting IDEA evaluation requirements,” referring to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.
In the classroom: Life skills classrooms are often overcrowded, the report says, with many “well beyond recommended capacity.” The district adopted a curriculum for self-contained classrooms but has not provided clear guidance on how to use it. Placement decisions are often “ad hoc,” and some students are sent to classrooms away from their home campus without data showing they need a more restrictive setting.
What’s next: The report recommends a three- to five-year strategic plan and says the district should not try to implement every recommendation at once. It ranks three areas as highest priority: student safety and crisis response, written procedures, and behavior support.
In September, district administration reported that all nine goals in MISD’s five-year special education strategic plan are currently on track but did not explain how or why. MISD last reported that they serve 3,652 students in special education, 618 students in its dyslexia program, and 965 students through Section 504 plans.